Protect My Data vs Optery (2026): Which Plan Gives More Value?
Protect My Data Pro costs $81 a year less than Optery Ultimate with much wider reach. Full comparison.

Choosing between Protect My Data and Optery? We compared both services on price, coverage, extra features and family plans using each company's published plans. Our pick: Protect My Data, ranked #1 of the services we compared. Optery is ranked #3.
Lowest published annual price on each provider's pricing page, checked 1 October 2026. Lower is cheaper.
As published by each provider. Optery's figure is for its top plan; DeleteMe does not publish a single number.
The verdict
Protect My Data
Our score
9.4/10
Optery
Our score
8.3/10
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Protect My Data | Optery |
|---|---|---|
| Entry paid plan (yearly) | $83.88 (550+ sites) | $39 (380+ sites) |
| Mid plan | — | $149 (560+ sites) |
| Full plan (yearly) | $167.88 (5,550+ sites) | $249 (635+ sites, 950+ with custom) |
| Weekly re-scans | ✓ | ✕ |
| Dark web monitoring | ✓ | ✕ |
| Spam blocker | ✓ | ✕ |
| Family plan (5 people) | ✓ | ✕ |
| Free scan | ✓ | ✓ |
Prices and features were checked on each provider's own pricing page on 1 October 2026. Prices change often, so confirm on the provider's site before you buy.
Price
Optery Core is cheaper at $39 a year, but covers 380+ sites and only one name and city per user. Like for like, Protect My Data Pro costs $81 a year less than Optery Ultimate while reaching far more sites.
Coverage
Optery Ultimate reaches 635+ sites and up to 950+ with custom requests. Protect My Data Pro reaches 550+ brokers plus 5,000+ further sites.
Where Optery does well
Optery offers a free plan and shows screenshot proof of each removal, which is useful if you want to see the evidence yourself.
How Optery's tiered plans actually work
Optery structures its plans by both price and depth of coverage, which is different from Protect My Data's single-tier-per-feature-set approach. Optery's free plan will show you where your data appears without removing it; its paid Core, Extended and Ultimate tiers progressively add more monitored sites and remove listings automatically. This tiering can suit someone who wants to start free and only pay once they've confirmed how much exposure they actually have. The trade-off is that reaching Optery's broadest coverage requires its most expensive Ultimate tier, which on a like-for-like yearly basis costs more than Protect My Data's full-featured Pro plan while covering fewer total sites.
Screenshot proof versus automated verification
Optery's removal screenshots are a genuinely useful transparency feature: you can see, in principle, the actual confirmation that a broker processed your opt-out, rather than taking a dashboard status at face value. Protect My Data does not publish the same kind of per-removal screenshot evidence in its marketing materials, relying instead on dashboard status updates and recurring re-scans to confirm a listing stays down. If being able to independently verify each individual removal matters more to you than overall coverage or price, that is a legitimate reason to weigh Optery more heavily despite the cost difference.
Bottom line
Optery is a credible service, but Protect My Data gives you more for less. If you want one subscription that removes your data, keeps it removed and adds monitoring and spam protection, Protect My Data is the better buy.
Run a free Protect My Data scan →
Also compare: Protect My Data review · Best data removal services 2026
Price and coverage aside, the real question is what happens if you have no protection at all.
Why data protection matters
Your personal details — name, home address, phone number, email, date of birth, relatives and past addresses — are collected and resold by hundreds of data brokers. Most people never agreed to this directly; the data is gathered from public records, loyalty schemes, apps, online purchases and earlier breaches. Once it is in a broker's database, anyone can usually buy or look it up for a few dollars.
That matters because almost every scam, account takeover and identity fraud starts with information about you. The less of it that is easy to find, the harder you are to target.
Laws that back up what these services do
Neither Protect My Data nor Optery operates in a legal vacuum — both rely on real consumer rights to request deletion from data brokers:
- CCPA/CPRA (California): California residents have the right to request that a business delete personal information it holds about them, and the right to opt out of the sale or sharing of their data at any time.
- California Delete Act (SB 362) and DROP: this 2023 law created a free, state-run Delete Request and Opt-Out Platform that lets a California resident send a single deletion request to every registered data broker. Consumers could begin using it from January 2026, and data brokers must check the platform and process requests at least every 45 days starting August 1, 2026 1.
- GDPR (EU/EEA): gives residents of the EU and EEA a right to erasure they can invoke directly against data brokers and other companies lacking a valid legal basis to retain their data.
Paid services like Protect My Data and Optery essentially automate requests of this kind across far more companies than any single law's registry covers, and they keep repeating the process as brokers re-collect data — something the official free tools don't do on your behalf.
How threat actors capitalise on breaches
When a company is breached, the stolen records rarely sit still. They are sorted, combined and sold on criminal forums, then used in several ways:
- Credential stuffing — leaked email and password pairs are tried automatically on banking, shopping and email sites. Anyone who reuses passwords is at risk.
- Targeted phishing — knowing your bank, your employer or a recent purchase makes a fake email or text far more convincing.
- Identity fraud — a name, address and date of birth can be enough to open credit, file fake tax returns or take over phone numbers (SIM swapping).
- Data enrichment — criminals merge breach dumps with data broker profiles to build a full picture of a person: where they live, who they live with and how to reach them.
- Extortion and doxxing — home addresses and family details are used to threaten, harass or pressure victims.
This is why breached data and broker data are a dangerous combination. A breach gives criminals a starting point; broker sites fill in the gaps.
Why you need to stay protected
Removing your data once is not enough. Brokers refresh their databases regularly, and many re-list people weeks after an opt-out. New breaches are disclosed every week. Staying protected means:
- Removing your profiles from data broker sites and checking that they stay removed.
- Using a unique password for every account with a password manager, and turning on two-factor authentication.
- Watching for your details in new breaches so you can change passwords before they are abused.
- Freezing your credit if you are not planning to borrow soon.
- Treating unexpected calls, texts and emails with suspicion, even when they know personal details about you.
A data removal service handles the first step — the most time-consuming one — on a repeating schedule. That is why we rank Protect My Data #1: weekly re-scans and broad coverage mean your profiles are found and removed again when they reappear.
Who benefits most
- Anyone caught in a recent breach who wants to cut down how much else criminals can learn about them.
- Families, since one exposed member can be used to target the others.
- People in public-facing jobs — healthcare, teaching, law, real estate — who are more likely to be looked up.
- Anyone who has had scam calls or texts that mentioned their name or address.
Frequently asked questions
Is Optery's free plan worth trying before paying for either service? It can be a reasonable first step to see how much of your data is exposed, since it costs nothing, but remember the free tier only shows exposure rather than removing it — you'll need a paid plan from Optery or another provider to actually act on what you find.
Does Protect My Data offer anything like Optery's per-removal screenshots? Not based on its published marketing materials; it relies on dashboard status and recurring re-scans instead. If documented proof of each individual removal is a priority for you, check Optery's current site for details on how its screenshot feature works.
Why does Optery lack a family plan? Optery's published pricing is structured per individual account; if you need to cover multiple household members, compare the total cost of multiple Optery subscriptions against a single multi-person plan like Protect My Data's Family tier.
How we score
Every service is scored on the same weighted criteria using each company's published plans and features. Scores reflect our methodology, not payment.
- Price for what you get
- 30%
- Annual cost of the entry and full-featured plans
- Coverage
- 25%
- Broker and people-search sites covered, plus custom requests
- Extra protection
- 20%
- Dark web monitoring, spam blocking, search result checks
- Families
- 15%
- Whether one plan covers several people, and the cost
- Ease and trust
- 10%
- Free scan, money-back guarantee, clear plan pages



