US Cyber Chief Defends Plan to Let Firms Hack Criminals
National Cyber Director Sean Cairncross says a vetted program letting companies disrupt foreign cybercrime gangs is not the "Wild West".
The US National Cyber Director, Sean Cairncross, has defended the government's plan to let private companies hack foreign cybercrime gangs, Cybersecurity Dive reports.
The program
- President Trump announced it in August, through a presidential notice stating that American businesses' "innovative capabilities have historically been under-utilised in efforts to identify and disrupt criminal networks operating in cyberspace," and that by partnering with "vetted US companies subject to the direction and oversight of the federal government," the administration aims to "enhance our ability to counter transnational criminal organisation threats and combat transnational cyber crime, fraud and other predatory schemes against American citizens" [[4]](https://www.thenationalnews.com/future/technology/2026/08/13/hack-back-trump-cyber-security/).
- The Justice Department and Homeland Security will vet companies' proposals to disrupt foreign gangs' computer systems.
- The government will oversee operations, make sure they do not clash with military or intelligence activity, and check they follow US law.
"We're not talking about letters of marque. We're not talking about the Wild West," Cairncross said at a USTelecom event in Washington on September 30. "This is a very specific program, overseen by the government, to engage industry and allow us to scale our efforts to take some of these actors on" [[1]](https://www.cybersecuritydive.com/news/oncd-white-house-sean-cairncross-regulation-deterrence-ai/831768/). Cybersecurity Dive reported that these remarks were "some of the first from a senior government official about the initiative" since Trump's August announcement [[1]](https://www.cybersecuritydive.com/news/oncd-white-house-sean-cairncross-regulation-deterrence-ai/831768/).
Who is Sean Cairncross?
Cairncross is the US National Cyber Director, a role within the Executive Office of the President responsible for coordinating the country's cybersecurity strategy and policy across federal agencies. He previously served as CEO of the Millennium Challenge Corporation, a US government foreign aid agency [[3]](https://www.nextgov.com/cybersecurity/2026/03/national-cyber-director-doesnt-envision-industry-doing-offensive-hacking/412176/).
How the plan has evolved — and the earlier pushback
The idea of private-sector involvement in offensive cyber operations against foreign hackers has been debated for over a decade, often under the label "hack back." Robert Graham, chief executive of the cybersecurity firm Errata Security, dismissed the August announcement's novelty on social media, writing: "This has been discussed under the name 'hack back' over the last 15 years in the cyber-security community... The White House just slides this [notice] in without using the controversial names, hoping people wouldn't recognise it" [[4]](https://www.thenationalnews.com/future/technology/2026/08/13/hack-back-trump-cyber-security/).
Notably, Cairncross himself had pushed back on the "hack back" framing months earlier. In March 2026, after the administration released its national cyber strategy, he told an audience at Auburn University's McCrary Institute: "I'm not talking about the private sector, industry or companies engaging in a cyber offensive campaign... What I'm talking about are the technical capabilities, the ability of our private sector to illuminate the battlefield from what they're seeing, to inform and share information so that the USG [U.S. government] can respond to get ahead of things" [[2]](https://cyberscoop.com/national-cyber-strategy-private-sector-offensive-operations-sean-cairncross/). At that same event, he added more directly: "There's an enormous amount of capability on the private sector side... I'm not talking about private sector, industry or companies engaged in a cyber offensive campaign" [[3]](https://www.nextgov.com/cybersecurity/2026/03/national-cyber-director-doesnt-envision-industry-doing-offensive-hacking/412176/).
Those earlier comments framed private-sector involvement mainly as intelligence-sharing to help the government respond more effectively, rather than companies themselves carrying out intrusions. By the time of the August 2026 presidential notice and Cairncross's September remarks, the framing had shifted toward a more concrete, government-supervised program in which vetted companies could directly disrupt foreign gangs' computer systems, representing a notable evolution in how the administration is willing to describe the initiative publicly.
The concerns
Experts say it is unclear whether the program will meaningfully increase disruption of cybercrime. Some companies may join to win future contracts; others may stay away for fear of retaliation or accidentally hitting a foreign government's systems. Foreign Policy's Situation Report has framed the broader push as one that "could put private companies in a tough spot," questioning whether the incentive structure for businesses to participate — and the legal protection they would have if something goes wrong — has been fully worked out [[5]](https://foreignpolicy.com/2026/09/17/trump-cybersecurity-hack-back-private-companies-ai/?tpcc=recirc_latest062921).
Why it matters
So-called "hack back" has long been illegal for US companies under laws such as the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, which generally criminalizes unauthorized access to computer systems regardless of the hacker's motive. Even a supervised version is a major shift, and how it handles mistakes — such as attacking the wrong server, a real risk given how often cybercriminals route their operations through hijacked infrastructure belonging to innocent third parties — will decide whether it helps or harms.
Cairncross's other message
He also urged organizations to focus on security basics: patching, strong authentication and backups still stop most attacks. This emphasis on fundamentals echoes a consistent theme across his public remarks over the past year — that while offensive measures against foreign hacking groups attract headlines, most organizations are still being breached through well-known, preventable weaknesses rather than sophisticated nation-state techniques.
What organizations and businesses should do
- Do not assume this program changes what is legal for your own organization — unauthorized "hacking back" against attackers remains illegal for companies that are not part of the formally vetted program.
- If your organization is considering applying to participate, expect a vetting process led by the Justice Department and Homeland Security, and plan for significant legal and compliance oversight.
- Continue prioritizing the fundamentals Cairncross himself highlighted: patch promptly, enforce strong multi-factor authentication, and maintain tested backups — these remain the most effective defenses regardless of how the offensive program develops.
- Follow official guidance from CISA and ONCD as the program's rules and participating companies become clearer, since details were still emerging as of this reporting.
The broader context: a pattern of offensive cyber proposals
This is not the first time the idea of enlisting private companies to go on the offensive against hackers has resurfaced in US policy circles. CyberScoop noted that "the idea of enabling U.S. companies to undertake disruptive or offensive campaigns against malicious hackers... has regained currency in some GOP circles in recent years," with some companies expressing interest especially if the relevant laws were changed to make such activity more viable [[2]](https://cyberscoop.com/national-cyber-strategy-private-sector-offensive-operations-sean-cairncross/). The administration's national cyber strategy, released earlier in 2026, explicitly discussed "incentivizing companies to disrupt the networks of adversaries" as one of its strategic pillars, described internally as an effort to "shape adversary behavior" using legal, diplomatic and technical tools beyond just offensive hacking [[2]](https://cyberscoop.com/national-cyber-strategy-private-sector-offensive-operations-sean-cairncross/).
Sources & Verification
Additional reporting
- Cybersecurity Divecybersecuritydive.com
- CyberScoop: Trump administration isn't pushing companies to conduct cyber offense, national cyber director sayscyberscoop.com
- Nextgov/FCW: National cyber director doesn't envision industry doing offensive hackingnextgov.com
- The National: Will Trump's cyber-security plan allow private companies to 'hack back'?thenationalnews.com
- Foreign Policy: Trump's Offensive Cyber Policies Could Put Private Companies in a Tough Spotforeignpolicy.com



