Skip to content
Unlisted Report logoUnlisted ReportSubscribe
Reviews

Protect My Data vs DeleteMe (2026): Full Comparison

Protect My Data costs far less than DeleteMe, especially for families, and adds monitoring tools. Full comparison.

Our top-rated pickProtect My Data logo

Choosing between Protect My Data and DeleteMe? We compared both services on price, coverage, extra features and family plans using each company's published plans. Our pick: Protect My Data, ranked #1 of the services we compared. DeleteMe is ranked #4.

Cheapest yearly plan, 1 person
Protect My Data
$83.88
Incogni
$95.88
Optery (Core)
$39
DeleteMe
$129
Aura
$144

Lowest published annual price on each provider's pricing page, checked 1 October 2026. Lower is cheaper.

Data broker sites covered automatically
Protect My Data
550+
Optery
Up to 635+
Aura
425+
Incogni
420+

As published by each provider. Optery's figure is for its top plan; DeleteMe does not publish a single number.

The verdict

Winner

Protect My Data

Our score

9.4/10

vs

DeleteMe

Our score

7.9/10

Ready to go with the winner? Try Protect My Data →

Side-by-side comparison

FeatureProtect My DataDeleteMe
Entry plan (yearly)$83.88$129
Two-year option—$209 (1 person)
Family plan$179.88/yr (5 people)$499 per 2 years (4 people)
Broker sites (automated)550+Major broker sites
Extra sites5,000+Custom requests
Weekly re-scans✓✕
Dark web monitoring✓✕
Spam blocker✓✕
Free scan✓✓

Prices and features were checked on each provider's own pricing page on 1 October 2026. Prices change often, so confirm on the provider's site before you buy.

Price

DeleteMe's single-person plan costs $129 a year — about 54% more than Protect My Data Basic. Covering a family is where the gap grows: Protect My Data Family covers five people for $179.88 a year, while DeleteMe's family plan is $499 for two years for four people.

Features

DeleteMe sends privacy reports roughly every quarter and uses human reviewers. Protect My Data re-scans weekly on Pro and adds dark web monitoring and spam blocking that DeleteMe does not include.

How the two actually remove your data

Both services work by submitting opt-out or deletion requests to data broker sites on your behalf, then checking later to confirm the listing is gone. The practical difference buyers report is cadence and breadth: a service that only re-checks quarterly can leave a re-listed profile live for weeks before it's caught, while weekly re-scanning shortens that exposure window considerably. DeleteMe's use of human reviewers for some removals is a genuine point in its favor for complex or stubborn listings, since automated systems occasionally fail against brokers with non-standard opt-out forms. Whether that trade-off is worth DeleteMe's higher price depends on how much you value human review versus broader automated coverage and more frequent scanning.

Where DeleteMe does well

DeleteMe has operated since 2010 and has the longest public track record in this market.

What to check before switching or signing up

  • Confirm current broker counts and plan terms directly on each company's pricing page — both services update their site lists and prices periodically, and published numbers in any review (including this one) can go stale.
  • Decide if you need family coverage now or later. If you have a partner or children who also appear in broker databases, compare the per-person cost of each family plan rather than just the headline price.
  • Ask what "monitoring" actually covers. Some plans monitor only the sites they actively remove from; others add separate dark web or credit monitoring as a bundled extra. Read the feature list carefully rather than assuming parity.
  • Check the cancellation and refund policy on the provider's own site, since these terms are set by each company and can change without notice.

Bottom line

DeleteMe is a credible service, but Protect My Data gives you more for less. If you want one subscription that removes your data, keeps it removed and adds monitoring and spam protection, Protect My Data is the better buy.

Run a free Protect My Data scan →

Also compare: Protect My Data review · Best data removal services 2026

Before you decide between the two, it helps to understand what you are protecting yourself from.

Why data protection matters

Your personal details — name, home address, phone number, email, date of birth, relatives and past addresses — are collected and resold by hundreds of data brokers. Most people never agreed to this directly; the data is gathered from public records, loyalty schemes, apps, online purchases and earlier breaches. Once it is in a broker's database, anyone can usually buy or look it up for a few dollars.

That matters because almost every scam, account takeover and identity fraud starts with information about you. The less of it that is easy to find, the harder you are to target.

Relevant privacy laws you can use directly

You do not have to rely only on a paid service. US and EU law give you some direct tools, though they require action on your part:

  • CCPA/CPRA (California): California residents have the right to request that a business delete personal information it holds about them, and the right to opt out of the sale or sharing of that information at any time.
  • California Delete Act (SB 362) and DROP: passed in 2023, this law created a free Delete Request and Opt-Out Platform run by the California Privacy Protection Agency, letting residents send one deletion request to every registered data broker at once. Consumers could start submitting requests from January 2026, and registered brokers must check the platform and act on requests at least every 45 days starting August 1, 2026 1.
  • GDPR (EU/EEA): gives residents a right to erasure that can be exercised against any company, including brokers, that lacks a valid legal basis to keep processing their data.

A paid removal service is useful precisely because these official tools are jurisdiction-specific and manual — DROP, for example, only reaches brokers registered in California, while a subscription service works across hundreds of brokers nationwide on an ongoing schedule.

How threat actors capitalise on breaches

When a company is breached, the stolen records rarely sit still. They are sorted, combined and sold on criminal forums, then used in several ways:

  • Credential stuffing — leaked email and password pairs are tried automatically on banking, shopping and email sites. Anyone who reuses passwords is at risk.
  • Targeted phishing — knowing your bank, your employer or a recent purchase makes a fake email or text far more convincing.
  • Identity fraud — a name, address and date of birth can be enough to open credit, file fake tax returns or take over phone numbers (SIM swapping).
  • Data enrichment — criminals merge breach dumps with data broker profiles to build a full picture of a person: where they live, who they live with and how to reach them.
  • Extortion and doxxing — home addresses and family details are used to threaten, harass or pressure victims.

This is why breached data and broker data are a dangerous combination. A breach gives criminals a starting point; broker sites fill in the gaps.

Why you need to stay protected

Removing your data once is not enough. Brokers refresh their databases regularly, and many re-list people weeks after an opt-out. New breaches are disclosed every week. Staying protected means:

  1. Removing your profiles from data broker sites and checking that they stay removed.
  2. Using a unique password for every account with a password manager, and turning on two-factor authentication.
  3. Watching for your details in new breaches so you can change passwords before they are abused.
  4. Freezing your credit if you are not planning to borrow soon.
  5. Treating unexpected calls, texts and emails with suspicion, even when they know personal details about you.

A data removal service handles the first step — the most time-consuming one — on a repeating schedule. That is why we rank Protect My Data #1: weekly re-scans and broad coverage mean your profiles are found and removed again when they reappear.

Who benefits most

  • Anyone caught in a recent breach who wants to cut down how much else criminals can learn about them.
  • Families, since one exposed member can be used to target the others.
  • People in public-facing jobs — healthcare, teaching, law, real estate — who are more likely to be looked up.
  • Anyone who has had scam calls or texts that mentioned their name or address.

Frequently asked questions

Is DeleteMe's longer track record a reason to pick it over Protect My Data? Longevity is a reasonable signal of stability, but it isn't a substitute for comparing current price, coverage and scan frequency, which is where Protect My Data leads based on each company's published plans.

Do I need both a removal service and DROP? If you live in California, using the free DROP platform alongside a paid service can add coverage for state-registered brokers, though a broad subscription service already covers far more sites than DROP's scope.

Can I use either service outside the United States? Coverage and relevance vary by country since most of the brokers targeted are US-based; check each provider's own site for details on international coverage before buying.

Run a free Protect My Data scan →

By · Published · Updated · 11 min read

How we score

Every service is scored on the same weighted criteria using each company's published plans and features. Scores reflect our methodology, not payment.

Price for what you get
30%
Annual cost of the entry and full-featured plans
Coverage
25%
Broker and people-search sites covered, plus custom requests
Extra protection
20%
Dark web monitoring, spam blocking, search result checks
Families
15%
Whether one plan covers several people, and the cost
Ease and trust
10%
Free scan, money-back guarantee, clear plan pages

Read next