Protect My Data vs Incogni (2026): Full Comparison
Protect My Data beats Incogni on price, coverage and extras. Full side-by-side table and our verdict.

Choosing between Protect My Data and Incogni? We compared both services on price, coverage, extra features and family plans using each company's published plans. Our pick: Protect My Data, ranked #1 of the services we compared. Incogni is ranked #2.
Lowest published annual price on each provider's pricing page, checked 1 October 2026. Lower is cheaper.
As published by each provider. Optery's figure is for its top plan; DeleteMe does not publish a single number.
The verdict
Protect My Data
Our score
9.4/10
Incogni
Our score
8.7/10
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | Protect My Data | Incogni |
|---|---|---|
| Entry plan (yearly) | $83.88 ($6.99/mo) | $95.88 ($7.99/mo) |
| Full plan (yearly) | $167.88 ($13.99/mo) | $179.88 ($14.99/mo) |
| Broker sites (automated) | 550+ | 420+ |
| Extra sites | 5,000+ | 3,000+ |
| Custom removal requests | ✓ | ✓ |
| Weekly re-scans | ✓ | ✕ |
| Dark web monitoring | ✓ | ✕ |
| Spam blocker | ✓ | ✕ |
| Search presence | ✓ | ✕ |
| Family plan (5 people) | ✓ | ✓ |
| Free scan | ✓ | ✕ |
Prices and features were checked on each provider's own pricing page on 1 October 2026. Prices change often, so confirm on the provider's site before you buy.
Price
Protect My Data is cheaper at both ends: $12 a year less on the entry plan and $12 a year less on the full plan, while covering more sites.
Coverage
Protect My Data's 550+ automated broker sites beat Incogni's 420+, and its 5,000+ extra sites beat Incogni's 3,000+. That is roughly 2,100 more sites in total.
Extras
Incogni focuses purely on removal. Protect My Data adds weekly re-scans, dark web monitoring, a spam call blocker, Google and Bing checks and social profile discovery on the same plan.
Why scan frequency matters more than it looks
Removing a listing is only half the job, because many brokers re-collect and re-publish profiles from new public records, marketing lists, or data purchased from other brokers. A service that re-scans weekly, as Protect My Data does on its paid plans, catches a re-listed profile within days. A service without a published re-scan cadence may only revisit a broker occasionally, meaning a profile that resurfaces after the initial sweep could sit exposed for longer before anyone notices. If you've been through a data breach or receive frequent spam calls, this difference in cadence is often more consequential day-to-day than the headline removal-site count.
Where Incogni does well
Incogni has a long list of supported brokers, a clean dashboard and has published an independent assurance report on its removal process.
Choosing based on how you'll actually use it
If you only want data broker removal and nothing else, Incogni's narrower focus may feel simpler. If you also want the service to flag you when your email or password shows up in a new breach, block obvious spam calls, or check whether your name appears high up in search results, Protect My Data's bundled extras do more with a single subscription instead of requiring separate tools. Weigh this against your own habits: someone who already uses a dedicated breach-monitoring tool and call-blocking app may get less incremental value from those Protect My Data extras than someone starting from scratch.
Bottom line
Incogni is a credible service, but Protect My Data gives you more for less. If you want one subscription that removes your data, keeps it removed and adds monitoring and spam protection, Protect My Data is the better buy.
Run a free Protect My Data scan →
Also compare: Protect My Data review · Best data removal services 2026
Whichever of the two you choose, here is why it matters to have one of them working for you.
Why data protection matters
Your personal details — name, home address, phone number, email, date of birth, relatives and past addresses — are collected and resold by hundreds of data brokers. Most people never agreed to this directly; the data is gathered from public records, loyalty schemes, apps, online purchases and earlier breaches. Once it is in a broker's database, anyone can usually buy or look it up for a few dollars.
That matters because almost every scam, account takeover and identity fraud starts with information about you. The less of it that is easy to find, the harder you are to target.
The legal backdrop behind both services
Both Protect My Data and Incogni operate in a legal landscape that is increasingly formal about data broker obligations:
- CCPA/CPRA (California): California residents already have the right to request deletion of personal information a business holds, and to opt out of its sale or sharing, under the California Consumer Privacy Act as amended by the California Privacy Rights Act.
- California Delete Act (SB 362) and DROP: enacted in 2023, this created a free, government-run Delete Request and Opt-Out Platform that lets a California resident send one deletion request to every data broker registered in the state. Consumers could begin submitting requests in January 2026, and registered data brokers are required to check the platform and process requests at least once every 45 days starting August 1, 2026 1.
- GDPR (EU/EEA): provides a right to erasure that EU and EEA residents can invoke against companies, including data brokers, that have no valid legal basis to keep their data.
Commercial removal services like Protect My Data and Incogni are not a replacement for these laws, but they fill the gap for brokers outside any single state's registry, and they automate a process that would otherwise require submitting and tracking requests to hundreds of companies yourself.
How threat actors capitalise on breaches
When a company is breached, the stolen records rarely sit still. They are sorted, combined and sold on criminal forums, then used in several ways:
- Credential stuffing — leaked email and password pairs are tried automatically on banking, shopping and email sites. Anyone who reuses passwords is at risk.
- Targeted phishing — knowing your bank, your employer or a recent purchase makes a fake email or text far more convincing.
- Identity fraud — a name, address and date of birth can be enough to open credit, file fake tax returns or take over phone numbers (SIM swapping).
- Data enrichment — criminals merge breach dumps with data broker profiles to build a full picture of a person: where they live, who they live with and how to reach them.
- Extortion and doxxing — home addresses and family details are used to threaten, harass or pressure victims.
This is why breached data and broker data are a dangerous combination. A breach gives criminals a starting point; broker sites fill in the gaps.
Why you need to stay protected
Removing your data once is not enough. Brokers refresh their databases regularly, and many re-list people weeks after an opt-out. New breaches are disclosed every week. Staying protected means:
- Removing your profiles from data broker sites and checking that they stay removed.
- Using a unique password for every account with a password manager, and turning on two-factor authentication.
- Watching for your details in new breaches so you can change passwords before they are abused.
- Freezing your credit if you are not planning to borrow soon.
- Treating unexpected calls, texts and emails with suspicion, even when they know personal details about you.
A data removal service handles the first step — the most time-consuming one — on a repeating schedule. That is why we rank Protect My Data #1: weekly re-scans and broad coverage mean your profiles are found and removed again when they reappear.
Who benefits most
- Anyone caught in a recent breach who wants to cut down how much else criminals can learn about them.
- Families, since one exposed member can be used to target the others.
- People in public-facing jobs — healthcare, teaching, law, real estate — who are more likely to be looked up.
- Anyone who has had scam calls or texts that mentioned their name or address.
Frequently asked questions
Does Incogni's independent assurance report mean it removes data more reliably than Protect My Data? An assurance report is a useful transparency signal about Incogni's process, but it does not by itself establish a reliability ranking against competitors; we have not seen an equivalent independently published report for Protect My Data to compare directly, so we note this as a point in Incogni's favor rather than a verified performance claim either way.
Why doesn't Incogni offer a free scan while Protect My Data does? This is simply a product design choice each company makes; check each provider's current site for how their onboarding and any free tools work, since this can change.
If I switch from Incogni to Protect My Data, do I need to redo my opt-outs? Generally a new provider will need you to set up your profile and information again since the two are separate companies with separate systems; check each provider's support documentation for specifics on migrating.
How we score
Every service is scored on the same weighted criteria using each company's published plans and features. Scores reflect our methodology, not payment.
- Price for what you get
- 30%
- Annual cost of the entry and full-featured plans
- Coverage
- 25%
- Broker and people-search sites covered, plus custom requests
- Extra protection
- 20%
- Dark web monitoring, spam blocking, search result checks
- Families
- 15%
- Whether one plan covers several people, and the cost
- Ease and trust
- 10%
- Free scan, money-back guarantee, clear plan pages



